dyer, garofalo, mann, and schultz

Grocery Giveaway

Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, and Shultz will be holding a giveaway every week to help provide for Dayton and the surrounding areas. Each week, 5 people will win $50 Kroger eGiftcards and 1 person will a $100 Kroger eGiftcard. Winners will be chosen from the Miami Valley and throughout the surrounding communities. We will be asking for an address to confirm residence in the greater Dayton area and an email address to contact the winner.

We have been involved in settlements and verdicts for our clients totaling over 5 BILLION dollars!

Case Results

As a result of our commitment to our clients, Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, & Schultz sees fairly high settlements every month.

In the Community

Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, & Shultz works hard for the communities where we are located. For example, see events we've recently sponsored.

Resources & Guides

We want every person to have the best possible legal outcome. For instance, check out our free legal guides and resources.


Our past clients have a lot to say about their experience with our firm. For instance, see videos and reviews from our successful cases.


Estamos orgullosos de ser parte de la comunidad diversa de Ohio y se habla Ingles y Español.

When You need a Hometown

Personal Injury Lawyer

We’ve worked hard over the past twenty years to make a name for ourselves as The Tiger Lawyer. In addition, the lawyers of Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, & Shultz are fluent in the laws of Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky. For instance, our high rate of success and higher than average settlement amounts speak for our commitment to our clients. We handle personal injury cases of Auto Accidents, Defective Products, Employment Law, Medical Malpractice, and Premise Liability. Although, many of our clients are not sure what kind of lawyer they need, not to worry.

DGMS offers free consultations and work on a contingency fee (i.e. We don’t get paid unless you do). If you have any questions about your case, or not sure if you have a case, we’re available by phone, email, or chat. In addition, you can meet the Tiger Lawyers in person at our main office in Dayton, Ohio. However, when you meet with a Tiger Lawyer in person you won’t leave empty handed. Before you leave don’t forget to grab your free t-shirts, pop sockets, pens, mugs, and more. 

Play Video

However, you don’t have to travel all the way to Dayton, Ohio for the expertise of our personal injury lawyers. We have many hometown locations across Ohio where you can find the lawyer for your personal injury needs. In any case, if you have suffered an injury because of someone else’s actions, you may be entitled to compensation. Above all, reach out to our experienced personal injury attorneys. We’re here to help.

Stay Up to Date

Why choose us?

The Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, & Shultz 30 Years of Clients Approach

DGMS has been roaring on to your tv set for the past thirty years. However, we’re more than just the lawyer that transforms into the Tiger. We’re the law firm that has been working toward providing legal protections for everyone in our community. For instance, we’ve been busy creating guides and videos that take you step by step through any type of case. In addition, we’ve been working with Equality Ohio to create videos explaining rights and legal action for our LGBTQ+ community. Above all, we strive to make the law easier and within reach for people across the nation.

I interacted with multiple attorneys, all of which were personable and very helpful. Staff communicated effectively and always responded same day. They were flexible with my schedule and made my experience as painless as possible.Karley FischerFebruary 20, 2021
I will turn to the tiger for all my legal issues in the future.Emanuel ColemanFebruary 12, 2021
My experience with Dyer, Garofalo, Mann & Schultz was amazing! I can't thank Attorney Ken Ignozzi enough for everything he did for me. I was in a car accident and the other driver totaled my car and I was hurt physically and I will probably never be the same. However, I was in such good legal hands, and Ken Ignozzi certainly held my hand the entire way. He was so professional, so very knowledgeable and extremely kind. I thought the legal process was going to be a mess but it wasn't at all for me - because I had a top notch attorney and I'm extremely grateful! The fee was more than reasonable and I was pleasantly surprised with the wonderful legal outcome thanks to Ken. I would recommend this firm and Ken Ignozzi very highly!Kathryn PanstingelFebruary 11, 2021
Thier helping me get my social security back I have siezure disorder and lost itMark GauDecember 14, 2020
I was bitten very badly by a dog on the job, I went in and was treated with respect, dignity, friendship, and care. I am such a wildcard on emotions and situations that I procrastinated getting back to them for an entire year and that was all me, a year later and I had still not stopped receiving correspondence even after that long of silence on my end. When I thought it was too late they snapped right back how they acted in the beginning; caresmatic and respectful. They are so intelligent and responsible and it took a lot less time then I thought it would to recieve a very decent settlement even after all that time waiting. If I ever have another scenario like this I will call them without hesitation.alyssa teagueNovember 5, 2020
I was struck by a semi truck, and I went to these guys to help resolve my legal issues. Matt Notaro was assigned to my case and with the help of him and Vicki Robb they helped not only resolve my case, but they even helped find sources for medical care and therapy. And for that I am eternally grateful. Definitely recommend these guys if you ever run into legal problems involving accidents.Trevor WilliamsNovember 5, 2020
Number 1dawn voylesNovember 3, 2020
In 2018 I was involved in an auto accident with someone from Canada who refused to pay for the damages of my car and my medical bills. Matt Notaro and his team helped me not only get my car paid for and medical bills paid for but also helped me to get some extra money on top as well. Matt was professional and patient through the whole situation working with a Canadian insurance agency. I highly recommend!Michael TurnerOctober 6, 2020
A little bit of a rough start and miscommunication but everything turned out perfectly. These folks handled my case in the smartest way possible with the least amount of hassle. Great job guys thank you so much for settling this out of courtThe #truthwhispererSeptember 23, 2020
They answered my question over the phone to my satisfaction.janice johnsonAugust 20, 2020
These people are the best. They handled my personal injury case with the best outcome and I didn’t have to worry about fighting with the insurance company. They were patient, responsive and always professional with me. They would answer my questions anytime. My case took 2 years to settle and they carried me through every step. If you’re injured in Ohio, these people would be the first I would call!Lincoln HarrisonAugust 14, 2020
Katie DaleJuly 29, 2020
Took care of all needs.Benjamin JonesJuly 13, 2020
William KingJuly 12, 2020
My experience with your firm was very satisfying..Attorney Matt Notaro and Vicki Robb always kept me updated on my case. If I had questions, they always got back with me in a timely manner. Matt looked out for my best interest and always consulted me before a decision was made. I would recommend your firm to anyone in need of legal assistance.Christine MorganJune 24, 2020
After I was involved in an automobile over bicycle accident, I turned the claim over to Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, & Schultz. I must say I was greatly relieved that they handled all details of the claim. It means a lot during recovery not to have to handle negotiations with insurance companies and medical entities. My legal team handled all aspects of the somewhat lengthy claim process in a professional and expert manner. They were also friendly and courteous in their dealings with me. With Dayton as the center of cycling in Ohio, it's good to know someone has our back. Many thanks to my legal team: Matt, Vicki, and Lori. Great job!Donald PowersMarch 28, 2020
I feel that the tiger fought for my case. They kept me updated through out my whole process. I highly recommend this law firm, they are just the best.Ariana VegaMarch 27, 2020
Tim DaleMarch 24, 2020
They gave me great information on how to file for SSI. And for free helped me apply.Delow 2020March 14, 2020
Very pleasant to work with while handling my caseJeannette SmithMarch 6, 2020
Love this firm!Brian Thomasson, PLCMarch 1, 2020
Lita CarterFebruary 26, 2020
They helped answer questions for me about an uninsured motorist claim. He gave me free advice about how I needed to claim with my insurance and the man I spoke with was absolutely correct. ThanksThomas EwryFebruary 10, 2020
The best attorneys in Dayton, Ohio. Dyer, Garofalo, Mann, & Schultz handle everything and always have a great presence on the phone. I highly recommend the Tiger! Especially working with the great staff in their Dayton office.Kathrine NelbertsonFebruary 4, 2020
Nothing but good things to say about this law firm. They were amazing during a very difficult time in my family's life. Attorney Pierre Tismo is a game changer, the best. His assistant Lindsay Donelson is very professional and caring. Would recommend 💯.Chris GrinerJanuary 23, 2020
Very complicated case, since I was involved in two auto accidents within a 3-week time-frame. My attorney, Pierre Tismo, did an excellent job in negotiating both suits. His assistant, Lindsey Donelson, was always quick to respond to my questions and concerns. They were always concerned about my physical needs and always treated me with great respect. If I could give them 10 stars, I would.Reba GilbertJanuary 22, 2020
Hilda NicewanerJanuary 14, 2020
Must give the tiger a chance.Marvenia StevensonJanuary 3, 2020
Professional, caring, customer driven firm. If you are not sure where do you stand legally. Go there and see them. If they can't help you for any reason they will direct you where to go. Best in Ohio. Highly recommended. Keep up the amazing job.Katy OmarDecember 23, 2019
I had the pleasure of dealing with him as my attorney a long time ago and I will always use him and any situation that I haveMarlene StoneDecember 9, 2019
puellaNovember 25, 2019
Call Now ButtonContact a Lawyer Skip to content