Can You Sue a Doctor For Misdiagnosis?

A medical misdiagnosis is considered malpractice. Correctly diagnosing patients is a critical duty doctors face, and the consequences of misdiagnosis can be deadly, so let’s find out if can you sue a doctor for misdiagnosis.

For example, a patient might see a doctor with an odd collection of symptoms. The doctor might believe the patient has health anxiety and other mental health issues and fails to complete all the necessary tests to rule out physical conditions. In reality, the patient had a rare type of cancer, and the cancer progressed without timely treatment. Upon the proper diagnosis, the patient needed far more invasive treatment, including surgery, chemo, and radiation, than they would have needed with a proper diagnosis the first time.

If you believe you suffered preventable injuries or complications due to a medical misdiagnosis, please speak with our Ohio medical malpractice attorneys today to see if you can sue for medical misdiagnosis.

Understanding Medical Misdiagnosis

As is the case in any malpractice case, the doctor’s carelessness causes the patient preventable injury or illness. With a misdiagnosis, the doctor “guesses” what’s wrong with the patient instead of running all the proper tests and ruling possibilities out one by one.

Misdiagnosis could also come from the doctor misreading test results. Sometimes, doctors need to look beyond the surface of test results and confer with colleagues or other professionals. If they fail to complete a full analysis of results, a misdiagnosis can result.

Giving no diagnosis at all is another common form of misdiagnosis. A medical misdiagnosis makes the patient’s condition worse, delays correct medication and treatment, and may even cause wrongful death, meaning a most likely preventable death.

The bottom line is that it might involve negligent behavior when a doctor makes your health worse instead of better. To prove a misdiagnosis claim in court, the doctor’s error must have made the patient’s condition worse—if the misdiagnosis was simply an inconvenience, you probably do not have a viable malpractice case.

The Most Common Medical Misdiagnoses

Statistics show that about 5% of ailments are not correctly diagnosed. Millions of people are misdiagnosed in the emergency room every year, and around 250,000 of those people die due to the misdiagnosis. BIPOC communities and women are misdiagnosed at a rate 20-30% higher than other demographics.

Here are some of the most common conditions that are frequently misdiagnosed:

Cancer (one of the most commonly misdiagnosed conditions due to the often general nature of most cancer symptoms—pancreatic cancer, for example, has just a 3% survival rate because doctors simply can’t diagnose it until the patient is months away from death)
Lyme disease (misdiagnosed as everything from depression to Mono to the flu)
Breathing problems (misdiagnosed asthma as recurring bronchitis and vice versa)
Aortic aneurysm (misdiagnosed as a heart attack when, in fact, it’s not a blood flow blockage but rather a blood leak)
Infections (along with cancer, this is one of the most prevalent misdiagnoses)
Lupus/Fibromyalgia/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (these conditions are often confused with each other)
Blood clots (doctors simply don’t take the time with this diagnosis)
Strokes (also one of the most common missed diagnoses, which can quickly become lethal)
Parkinson’s (misdiagnosed as a stroke, anxiety, or even Alzheimer’s)
Celiac disease (misdiagnosed as irritable bowel syndrome, Crohn’s disease, or Cystic Fibrosis)

How a Medical Condition Can Be Misdiagnosed?

Often, misdiagnosis happens because doctors fail to ask the necessary questions or consider everything a patient says. What are some other common ways that true underlying medical conditions are misdiagnosed? Some include:

Failure to detect/acknowledge all symptoms, related or unrelated
Delayed diagnoses
Failure to do the right tests causes an incomplete picture of what is going on with the patient
Not correctly interpreting test results
Not acknowledging symptoms like pain and mental health issues
Failure to refer the patient to the right specialists, like a psychiatrist in the example above

The circumstances of a misdiagnosis can vary, but they can all cause worsening injuries and conditions. For example, imagine if an x-ray machine wasn’t properly calibrated and, therefore, showed a broken bone was not broken. In this case, the client was told to “walk it off” without a cast on, and this caused further injury and pain. The fact that a machine malfunction caused the misdiagnosis is irrelevant. If the doctor had taken the pain complaints more seriously, perhaps additional x-rays, scans, testing, and second opinions would have been sought to correctly identify the fracture.

No matter how your misdiagnosis happened, it is always worth it to seek a legal evaluation of your rights if you suffered preventable complications or required more invasive treatment.

How Common Are Misdiagnoses?

Misdiagnosis is a serious issue in the medical field that affects many individuals annually. According to recent research, about 371,000 deaths and 424,000 severe injuries result each year due to medical diagnoses across the U.S. Among these cases, strokes are the most frequently misdiagnosed condition that leads to serious harm.

A big portion of misdiagnoses involves what experts call the “Big Three” categories of medical conditions:

Heart events like heart attacks
Infections
Cancer

Also, there are other common ailments that frequently result in death or disability due to misdiagnosis. These include sepsis, pneumonia, and blood clots in veins (such as pulmonary embolism).

The study found that about 11% of medical problems overall result in a misdiagnosis, although this error rate varies by disease. For instance, the misdiagnosis rate for heart attacks is relatively low at 1.5%. However, the rate is 62% in the case of spinal abscesses.

Researchers stress the importance of reducing diagnostic errors. They estimate that cutting errors by 50% for conditions like stroke, sepsis, pneumonia, pulmonary embolism, and lung cancer could prevent 150,000 deaths and cases of permanent disability annually.

Can You Sue a Doctor for Misdiagnosis?

You have a legal right to sue a doctor for misdiagnosis due to their negligence. If a doctor provides a wrong diagnosis that causes harm or leads to further complications or a loved one’s death, Ohio law allows you to file a medical malpractice lawsuit.

However, proving a case against a professional medical doctor can be challenging due to their professional qualifications and expertise. You must seek expert testimony to establish whether the defendant doctor’s actions deviated from the standard of care, and this is a job for your medical malpractice attorney in Dayton.

What Are the Consequences of Medical Misdiagnosis?

Misdiagnosing medical conditions can lead to severe consequences for patients. Here are some of the potential consequences of medical misdiagnosis:

Delayed treatment. When a patient receives a misdiagnosis, it can delay receiving the appropriate care.
Physical harm. Misdiagnosis can result in injuries from unnecessary interventions.
Emotional distress. The uncertainty, confusion, and anxiety that come with a misdiagnosis may cause fear, frustration, anger, and distrust of the healthcare system.
Financial burden. Unnecessary treatments can result in significant healthcare costs for hospitalizations and ongoing care.
It is worsening of the condition. Misdiagnosis leads to reduced chances of successful treatment outcomes and a higher risk of long-term complications or disabilities.

What if the Hospital May Be Liable?

The hospital itself can contribute to the misdiagnosis, either through systemic issues, staffing problems, or inadequate protocols. In such a case, there might be grounds to hold the hospital liable. This typically requires demonstrating that the hospital’s negligence contributed directly to the misdiagnosis and subsequent harm.

What Kind of Compensation Can I Get for Misdiagnosis?

The compensation for medical misdiagnosis varies depending on the unique circumstances attached to your case. It is the work of the Ohio medical malpractice lawyer to assess the impact of misdiagnosis and document the damages for which to seek compensation. These might include the following:

Medical expenses. Reimbursement for past and future medical costs incurred due to the misdiagnosis.
Lost wages. Compensation for income lost due to inability to work.
Pain and suffering. Payment for physical pain and emotional distress caused by the misdiagnosis.
Loss of consortium. Redress for the impact on personal relationships and family life.
Wrongful death. When a misdiagnosis leads to a preventable death, families can seek compensation and justice.

Proving actual damages is important for a winning medical misdiagnosis claim in Ohio. Your injury lawyer will show all economic and non-economic losses due to the misdiagnosis to ensure adequate compensation.

Suing a Doctor for Medical Misdiagnosis

Doctors are required by law to provide a high-level standard of care. When physicians fail to do so, they can be liable for medical malpractice. In order to be successful in suing a doctor for medical misdiagnosis, you’ll need to be able to prove all the elements of a malpractice case. This is a complex legal principle, so you want a skilled medical malpractice lawyer handling the process.

You’ll need documentation, medical records, and any other relevant evidence. If a thorough, competent doctor with similar education/experience would have come to the right diagnosis under the circumstances, your doctor may indeed be liable for malpractice.

The goal of a medical misdiagnosis lawsuit is to recover damages for pain and suffering, extraneous medical expenses, lost income (past and future), and any other related losses. While money will never erase your preventable injuries or medical condition, it can provide financial support and justice for your family.

Your first step is to contact a medical misdiagnosis attorney. The lawyer will ask you any questions necessary to figure out whether you have a strong case or not and can advise you about any missing information or documentation you may need to obtain. Be sure to bring everything you have relating to your case with you to the legal consultation.

Your lawyer will be looking for ways to maximize your compensation, strengthen your case, and prove your doctor’s negligence. Your medical malpractice lawyer may even advise you to get second opinions and confer with additional specialists, and so on. While you take care of those tasks, your legal team will be having expert witnesses in the medical field review your case and hopefully agree to testify on your behalf.

Your case must be filed within Ohio’s set time limit (“statute of limitations”). In Ohio, you have less time than some other states allow to bring a personal injury claim—just two years from the injury date. However, there are stricter requirements under the law if your injury stems from malpractice. In Ohio, you must:

Provide notice of an intended lawsuit to the liable professional within one year of the injury
File your lawsuit within 180 days of providing notice

Once your lawyer has initiated the lawsuit, settlement negotiations may begin right away, or there could be a series of hearings and depositions (giving recording testimony in your lawyer or the other lawyer’s office) that ultimately lead to a trial. Most medical malpractice cases are resolved out of court, though some require going to trial.

Your attorney can advise on what you might expect from the process after they review what happened.

Four Elements You Must Prove to Win a Malpractice Suit

You must prove four elements of malpractice to successfully show your doctor is indeed liable for your medical injuries:

You must prove you had an established doctor-patient relationship with the physician in question. A doctor you ran into at the supermarket and asked about your symptoms does not have a duty to provide you with care.
You must show your doctor failed to meet the accepted standard of care—the doctor was not reasonably thorough, disregarded information you gave (pain level, medical history), failed to do a sufficient follow-up, and so on. This is where you will need an expert witness or two who can testify that, based on their skills and experience, a doctor acting with a proper standard of care would have made the correct diagnosis and/or made the correct diagnosis faster.
You must demonstrate that the misdiagnosis made your health worse and caused you harm. For example, if you got a second opinion from another doctor the following week, and the second doctor gave you the right diagnosis, then the first doctor isn’t likely to be liable for misdiagnosing you.
Finally, you’ll need to somehow quantify the damages you’ve suffered (pain, stress, lost income, property damage, permanent disability, etc). A court might consider medical bills, journal entries, testimony from a therapist, statements from people close to you, and pertinent physical evidence (eviction notice, termination notice, divorce decree, etc).

Proving all of these elements requires the assistance of an experienced malpractice injury attorney.

Need an Ohio Medical Malpractice Lawyer?

At Dyer, Garofalo, Mann & Schultz, we take medical malpractice cases very seriously. Your doctor is supposed to help you, not hurt you. Can you sue a doctor for misdiagnosis? yes, so allow us to advocate for you. Don’t be intimidated by the medical industry and insurance companies. You have important rights as an injured patient. Contact our Ohio malpractice attorneys through our contact form or call us at 1.937.222.2222

Before establishing Dyer, Garofalo, Mann & Schultz L.P.A., Doug Mann, a top Ohio Injury Attorney served as a bodily injury claims adjuster at a major insurance firm. With over 40+ years of experience, Doug’s background has proven invaluable in securing maximum cash settlements for his clients swiftly. Since leaving the insurance industry, Doug has devoted his entire legal career to assisting injured clients during their times of greatest need.